Economic Fallacies5 November 2026

One Man’s Gain Is Another’s Loss

Free exchange benefits both sides

Praxeologos

Pencil drawing: two hands exchanging a loaf of bread and a small tool over a counter, with a faint golden line between them.

The fallacyIn the market whoever gains always gains at someone else’s expense; trade is a game in which one takes what the other loses.

What is seen

A merchant makes a profit, a doctor earns a high fee, a country exports more than it imports. It is easy to see that “someone paid” for their gains.

What is not seen

The buyer would not give his money if he did not prefer what he gets. The seller would not sell if he did not prefer the money. Value is subjective: each gives something he values less for something he values more, and that is why both come out ahead.

The entrepreneur’s profit is not his customer’s loss; it is his reward for foreseeing correctly what others would need and offering it to them. The doctor does not profit from the disease but from the cure. One man’s gain as another’s loss holds only for robbery and war, where something is taken by force.

The Austrian viewVoluntary exchange is not a zero-sum game. Profit in a free market is the signal that resources were used where consumers wanted them most. Mises called the opposite idea “the Montaigne dogma” and showed that it lies at the root of mercantilism and economic nationalism.

In the original“The deal is always advantageous both for the buyer and the seller.”

Ludwig von Mises, Human Action, XXIV. Harmony and Conflict of Interests · 1. The Ultimate Source of Profit and Loss on the Market, p. 665 · mises.org ↗

Further reading: Per Bylund, How to Think about the Economy: A Primer (Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2022), ch. 3, “How to Do Economics” (The Meaning of Exchange) · mises.org ↗

Underlined terms open their definition from the Glossary · all fallacies

Definitions are from the site’s Glossary; the explanation is Praxeologos’s reading. Where marked “Translation: Praxeologos”, the rendering of the passage is our own. Links to outside sources open in a new tab.

← Economic FallaciesAll fallacies