Subsidies Save the Industry
Whatever is saved by subsidy, other industries pay for, unseen
Praxeologos

The fallacyAn industry in trouble must be saved with subsidies or protection, or jobs will be lost and the slump will spread.
What is seen
The industry receives the subsidy and keeps its plants open. Its workers and the local shops around it are relieved. A subsidy at the pump or on rent makes the price look lower.
What is not seen
The subsidy money came from everyone else’s taxes, or from new debt. The industries that would have earned it from their customers, and would have grown, stay smaller. Labor and capital are held where consumers want them less, instead of going where they want them more.
When the subsidy goes to demand, as with fuel or rents, supply does not increase: the extra money raises prices or ends up with the sellers. And every subsidy creates a group that will fight to keep it forever.
The Austrian viewThe market works through profit and loss: losses are the signal that resources are needed elsewhere. A subsidy silences that signal for the sake of pressure groups with access to power, and opens the way to cronyism and rent seeking. Progress requires that old industries can shrink, as the carriage gave way to the motor car.
In the original“Paradoxical as it may seem to some, it is just as necessary to the health of a dynamic economy that dying industries be allowed to die as that growing industries be allowed to grow.”Henry Hazlitt, Economics in One Lesson (1946), ch. 14, “Saving the X Industry”, p. 87 (Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2008) · mises.org ↗
For kidsThe Chief’s ShareRoko gives away a coconut he first took from Friday.Book · 12 pages- Henry Hazlitt
- Current affairs: “Subsidies at the Pump: Who Pays for Cheaper Gasoline?”
- Current affairs: “Rent Refund: Subsidizing Demand Builds No Houses”
- Current affairs: “Excess Revenue from High Prices: What the State Gives, It Has First Taken”
- Murray N. Rothbard, Man, Economy, and State
- All economic fallacies
Further reading: Per Bylund, How to Think about the Economy: A Primer (Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2022), ch. 9, “Regulatory Intervention” (The Seen, The Unseen, The Unrealized) · mises.org ↗
Underlined terms open their definition from the Glossary · all fallacies
Definitions are from the site’s Glossary; the explanation is Praxeologos’s reading. Where marked “Translation: Praxeologos”, the rendering of the passage is our own. Links to outside sources open in a new tab.