Economic Fallacies5 November 2026

Public Works and “Job Creation”

Every job paid for by taxes is missing somewhere else

Praxeologos

Pencil drawing: a bridge under construction with scaffolding and, in the foreground, a half-open empty purse on a workshop table.

The fallacyGovernment spending and big public works create jobs and wealth.

What is seen

A bridge is announced. Hundreds of workers are hired, contractors sign agreements, there is a ribbon-cutting with photographs. All of this is seen, and credited to the government.

What is not seen

Every euro of the bridge came from some taxpayer, today through taxes or tomorrow through borrowing and new money. That taxpayer would have spent or invested it himself: on a house, a machine, a small business. The jobs he would have created will never exist, and nobody will cut a ribbon for them.

So the question is not whether the bridge “creates jobs” but whether it is worth more than what citizens themselves would have made with the same money. Government spending cannot know this, because it does not pass the test of prices, profit and loss. A structure may be useful; it does not create wealth merely because it employs people.

The Austrian viewPublic spending is a transfer of resources: taxation takes from those who produce and gives to those chosen by political power. What is seen are the beneficiaries; what is not seen are the investments and purchases that never happened. What the state gives, it has first taken.

In the original (French)«L’État ouvre un chemin, bâtit un palais, redresse une rue, perce un canal ; par là, il donne du travail à certains ouvriers, c’est ce qu’on voit ; mais il prive de travail certains autres ouvriers, c’est ce qu’on ne voit pas.»

Translation: Praxeologos“The State opens a road, builds a palace, straightens a street, digs a canal; by this it gives work to certain workers, that is what is seen; but it deprives certain other workers of work, that is what is not seen.”

Frédéric Bastiat, Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas (July 1850), ch. 5, “Travaux publics” · fr.wikisource.org ↗

Further reading: Per Bylund, How to Think about the Economy: A Primer (Ludwig von Mises Institute, 2022), ch. 9, “Regulatory Intervention” (The Seen, The Unseen, The Unrealized) · mises.org ↗

Underlined terms open their definition from the Glossary · all fallacies

Definitions are from the site’s Glossary; the explanation is Praxeologos’s reading. Where marked “Translation: Praxeologos”, the rendering of the passage is our own. Links to outside sources open in a new tab.

← Economic FallaciesAll fallacies