Praxeology in Current AffairsTaxation
A €7.78 Billion Primary Surplus: The State Did Not Find This Money; It Took It
What happened. According to the provisional data on the execution of Greece’s state budget for the ten months from January to October 2026, as reported by Kathimerini, the primary surplus came to 7.78 billion euros, against a target of 4.823 billion euros. In the same period of 2025 it was 10.248 billion euros. After excluding timing shifts in payments — 766 million euros of the Public Investment Programme, 201 million in defence procurement, and 811 million in transfer payments to general-government entities — as well as 135 million euros from the casino licence at Elliniko, the net overshoot versus the target narrows to 1.044 billion euros. Tax revenue came to 62.872 billion euros; excluding the amounts from the Egnatia Odos concession and the casino licence, it was 62.431 billion euros, 1.654 billion or 2.7% above the target. Net revenue reached 64.4 billion euros, exceeding the target by 2.7 billion euros. Expenditure came to 64.291 billion euros, 203 million euros above the target — the ministry attributes this mainly to faster payments under the Recovery and Resilience Facility — and 6.407 billion euros higher than in the same ten months of 2025. On the ordinary budget, payments were 964 million euros below the target (Kathimerini, November 17). The overall budget balance shows a surplus of 120 million euros, against a target deficit of 2.403 billion euros (Naftemporiki, November 16).
The praxeological view. The word “surplus” makes it sound as if something was left over, as if the treasury had succeeded in finding more money than it needed. In fact it is the difference between what the state collected from households and firms and what it spent in the same period. The 7.78 billion euros did not appear in the public coffers. They were already the incomes of taxpayers, before they were collected as tax. The same is true of the overall balance: the target was a deficit, and a surplus of 120 million euros now appears. That sum, too, did not come from nowhere.
The comparison with the target can mislead as well. The gap from the 4.823 billion euros looks like almost three billion of “overperformance.” After the timing adjustments Kathimerini records, the net overshoot is 1.044 billion euros: part of the picture is payments that were postponed. And relative to last year, the primary surplus did not rise; it fell.
What is seen is the public accounts: a surplus, revenue above target, the language of “overperformance.” What is not seen is what taxpayers would have done with the same money — consumption, saving, investment. The opportunity cost does not appear in the budget-execution bulletin.
Frédéric Bastiat, in That Which Is Seen and That Which Is Not Seen, puts it in an image that fits this presentation of the surplus as a flourishing of the public finances:
“You may compare the nation to a parched stretch of land and the tax to a fertilizing rain. Very well. But you should also ask where this rain comes from, and whether it is not the very same tax that draws the moisture from the soil and dries it out.”
The opposite of a surplus is not, by itself, a private prosperity that appears automatically. A deficit means that the state spent even more than it took in, covering the difference by borrowing or by issuing new money. Neither sum was born in the public treasury.
In the note on excess revenue from high prices we examined how a VAT overshoot, which follows prices, returns in part as “support.” Here the question is a different one. It is not whether the surplus is “enough” for new measures, nor whether it should be handed back in the same way. It is what a primary surplus is: money already taken, which in this period did not return as public spending.
The bulletin records that the treasury came out ahead. It does not record from which plans, purchases and savings this remainder was subtracted.
See also: Frédéric Bastiat, That Which Is Seen and That Which Is Not Seen («Τι φαίνεται και τι δεν φαίνεται»), chapter “Taxes” · Excess Revenue from High Prices: What the State Gives, It Has First Taken — Glossary: taxation · opportunity cost · saving — Map of Ideas: taxpayers and tax-consumers