Praxeology in Current AffairsInflation
Inflation at 5.6%: Energy Does Not Print Euros
What happened. According to Eurostat’s flash estimate of November 4, Greece’s harmonised index of consumer prices (HICP) stood at 5.6% year on year in October 2026, up from 5.1% in September and from 1.6% in October 2025; month on month, Greek prices rose by 0.4%. In the 21-country euro area the corresponding rate is estimated at 4.0%, up from 3.8% the month before. Greece, together with Italy, records the third-highest annual rate in the euro area, after Lithuania (6.1%) and Bulgaria (6.0%) (Eurostat; SKAI, November 4). For individual countries the preliminary estimate gives only the headline annual and monthly rates; the split by category (energy, food, services, goods) is published for the euro area as a whole, and the full set of October figures for the Member States is scheduled for November 18. In the euro area, energy had the highest annual rate in October (20.8%, from 18.9% in September), followed by services (3.3%), food, alcohol and tobacco (1.6%) and non-energy industrial goods (1.2%); the index excluding energy, food, alcohol and tobacco stayed at 2.5%. The Greek and international press attribute the rise mainly to energy and call it “imported” (SKAI; Kathimerini, November 5).
The praxeological view. The 5.6% measures how much more expensive a basket of goods and services became in a year. It does not by itself say why prices rose, and still less what inflation. In the Austrian tradition inflation is not the rise in the price index; it is the increase in the quantity of money. Murray N. Rothbard defines it without euphemism in What Has Government Done to Our Money?:
“Inflation may be defined as any increase in the economy’s supply of money not consisting of an increase in the stock of the money metal. Fractional reserve banks, therefore, are inherently inflationary institutions.”
Relative price and the general level. A rise in the price of energy is first of all a change in relative prices: oil, natural gas or electricity became dearer relative to other goods. That signals scarcity of those goods and pushes households and firms to use them more sparingly and to look for substitutes. If the quantity of money stayed fixed, more euros for energy would mean fewer euros for other goods; some prices would rise, others would fall or rise less, and the general index would not have to follow energy one way. When almost the whole basket rises, the question shifts from which price moved first to whether more euros are in circulation. The preliminary estimate for the euro area itself shows that it was not only energy that moved: services and non-energy industrial goods also post positive annual rates, and the index excluding energy, food, alcohol and tobacco remains at 2.5%. The word “imported” describes where the initial shock to a relative price came from; it does not by itself explain why the purchasing power of the euro falls across a wide front. The euro is fiat money: its quantity is not bound to a metal stock, and it is set by the central bank and the banking system through credit expansion.
Who pays. The new money does not reach everyone at once. It goes first to those nearest its source — banks, borrowers, those who sell to them — and is spent while prices have not yet risen. Last to meet it are the wage earner, the pensioner and whoever holds cash, when prices have already gone up (the Cantillon effect). Rothbard describes it as a race:
“Inflation, then, confers no general social benefit; instead, it redistributes the wealth in favor of the first-comers and at the expense of the laggards in the race. And inflation is, in effect, a race—to see who can get the new money earliest.”
That is why a debate that stops at “imported high prices” leaves the essential aside. Energy can explain which price moved first; it does not explain who prints the euros that chase the same goods. As we wrote of the ECB and of excess revenue from high prices, as long as money can be multiplied at will, rising prices will return, and with them the search for an outside culprit. The question is not whether energy is dearer; it is why the euro loses purchasing power — and the answer runs through the quantity of money, not the barrel.
See also: Murray N. Rothbard, What Has Government Done to Our Money? · ECB: When a Committee Sets the Price of Time · Excess Revenue from High Prices: What the State Gives, It Has First Taken — Glossary: inflation · money supply · purchasing power · sound money — Map of Ideas: inflation