Economic Fallacies5 November 2026

The Broken Window

Destruction does not create wealth

Praxeologos

Pencil drawing: the broken window of a small shop and, faintly in the background, a suit that was never made.

The fallacyWhen something is destroyed, repairing it “creates work”, so destruction is good for the economy.

What is seen

A boy breaks a shop window. The glazier comes, replaces it and is paid. The crowd that gathers consoles the shopkeeper: “Glaziers have to live too.” The same argument is heard after earthquakes, fires and wars: “rebuilding will boost growth.”

What is not seen

The money paid for the new pane is money the shopkeeper would have spent elsewhere: on a suit, a book, a tool for his shop. The tailor who lost the order will never appear in any statistic, because the suit was never made.

So the account is simple: before the damage, society had a window and was about to have a suit as well; after it, it has only the window. Work is not an end in itself; its purpose is the goods it produces. Whatever the disaster, the means spent to rebuild what already existed are its opportunity cost: everything that would have been made instead.

The Austrian viewThe fallacy sees only two people, the shopkeeper and the glazier, and forgets the third, the one the same money would have served. A society’s wealth is its stock of goods and capital, not the movement of money. Destruction shrinks it, however “busy” it keeps us.

In the original (French)«Votre théorie s’arrête à ce qu’on voit, elle ne tient pas compte de ce qu’on ne voit pas.»

Translation: Praxeologos“Your theory stops at what is seen; it takes no account of what is not seen.”

Frédéric Bastiat, Ce qu’on voit et ce qu’on ne voit pas (July 1850), ch. 1, “La vitre cassée” · fr.wikisource.org ↗

For kidsThe Broken WindowBook · 12 pages

Underlined terms open their definition from the Glossary · all fallacies

Definitions are from the site’s Glossary; the explanation is Praxeologos’s reading. Where marked “Translation: Praxeologos”, the rendering of the passage is our own. Links to outside sources open in a new tab.

← Economic FallaciesAll fallacies